Proxmox vs VMware

Proxmox vs VMware

I am evaluating using Proxmox instead of VMware (free license) for my VMs. I am writing down some of my thoughts for later reference. I have not used Proxmox so these thoughts are based on my research.

Proxmox pros and cons

  • Comes with backup and restore even for the free license
  • Easier management
  • Supports zfs, and some support for zfs encryption
  • Can be configured to support LUKS (some work involved)
  • Does not work with Synology Active Backup for Business
  • ZFS or BTRFS is more performant in terms of snapshots (but the snapshots cannot be backed up)

VMware pros and cons

  • Can run off USB drive (deprecated in future versions)
  • Difficult to set up backup in free version
  • Does not support encryption

My current pain points with VMware

  • Web GUI is a pain
  • I am worried about screwing up the VMs while using the Web GUI (such as forgetting to enter/exit maintenance mode)
  • Difficult to back up the USB flash drive
  • Setting up backup (changed block tracking, SSH, etc.) for a new host is a pain and error prone
  • Less confidence the restore would work
  • No encryption

Summary

For my use case, I already have VMware set up and working, with integrated Active Backup. I like the fact I can install an ESXi host on a USB drive, which makes restoring to a new host easier. Also, if I migrate to Proxmox I might have to reconfigure my Windows VM, etc. On the other hand, the VMware GUI is a pain, and I am always worried I might make a mistake and screw up my VMs. Also my VMs are not encrypted.